Some say salmon farming is the major local employer in Huon, as well as being a major industry for the whole of the state, and it would be economically and socially devastating if it was forced to close.

Others say that salmon farming is impacting the local’s enjoyment of their beaches and beachside properties, and seriously harming the environment – and they want it to close, if it will not move away from the sheltered waters of the Huon and Channel, or come entirely onshore.

This presents us with a problem, which is dividing the community. It would not be a hard problem to solve if we could dismiss one or other of these points of view as unfounded, as something that does not need to be taken seriously. But what if both are true? Then we have a hard problem. Let’s assume that is what we have and see what we can do to resolve the issue. As a candidate for Huon I should have a go at this at least to give you a clear indication of how I approach hard problems (there will be a lot facing whoever is elected as your representative for Huon in the Legislative Council), even if I am not in a position to propose a thorough solution. Which I am not right now. With an expert inquiry established by the government after agreement with the cross bench yet to report, this is not the time to say with any certainty what the future of the salmon industry should look like. So while we wait for the report of the inquiry, what follows should be read with that caution in mind.

First we need to decide whether we want to solve the problem.  Not everyone wants to solve problems. Rather, on both sides of a dispute people can fall into cultivating problems, digging in to defend their positions. Trench warfare. And when challenged, they dig deeper, and note who else is ‘on their side’ and digging with them.

Particularly in an election, that is the safe thing to do. Shore up your base, gather every vote from your side and make sure voters know which side you are on, and expose the waverers as traitors.

It is much riskier to say, wars are never won by staying in your trench. You need to get out and into the field of contest, hoping to win over people from the opposing trench, and risk having to learn a bit and shift your position yourself.

That is more my style. I’m not a ‘my team right or wrong’ player. I don’t want to be stuck in my trench – particularly a muddy one. I’m an independent.

So when invited by Huon Aquaculture to tour their facilities at Point Huon, Dover and in the city, with a boat ride to pens in Flathead Bay, I agreed. I think it is fair to say they were a bit wary of me, and I was unsure of how I would be received,  having written here and in The Mercury on what I see as the dangers of salmon farming. And on my Facebook you’ll find evidence of me joining Peter George and Bob Brown at a recent Neighbours of Fish Farms rally at Eggs and Bacon Bay. So I accepted the invitation already with a researched view but willing to learn more, trying always to be a critical and creative thinker, and a problem solver. Refusing to consider the views of one side of a dispute does not sit well with me.

So I’m out of my trench and in no-person’s land – and now in danger of being shot by both sides. And possibly losing votes as well. But I will keep to the commitment I gave to my hosts at Huon. That I will think carefully about what they showed me and claimed to be true, and write about what I think I learned from that listening. That I won’t ambush them by raising a concern I did not put to them when I visited, but I will make clear what are my continuing concerns. After that, it’s up to the Huon Aquaculture folk to decide whether I am their new best friend or confirmed enemy. And vice, versa, as it were, for my friends who I joined at Eggs and Bacon Bay a couple of weeks ago. I leave it to you to judge whether I demonstrate a capacity to listen, learn and lead – or go to water, turning to sympathy and waffle when determination is needed.

First to the economic question. Using AI as a research assistant, I get Huon Aquaculture’s direct employment in the Huon electorate at between 300-500 jobs, with perhaps around another 100 in Hobart, and their activities contributing around $250-400m a year to the Tasmanian economy. Again using the figures AI gave me, the total value of the Tasmanian economy is around $45bn/year, and economic activity in Huon is (very roughly indeed)  considerably less than 10% of that – let’s guess $3bn.

Fish farming in the Huon Valley, Channel, Storm Bay and Pt Arthur, employs around 1,500 – but some estimates are much higher, up to 5,000, which seems unbelievable if you calculate what that would mean for labour productivity – and contributes around $650m/yr to the Tasmanian economy. Huon Aquaculture is about one third of the whole aquaculture industry in the south of the state.

So putting all that guestimate data together, we have: the Tasmanian economy is around $45bn/year; the economy of the Huon electorate is around $3.0bn a year; aquaculture in the south of the state contributes about $650m/year to the state economy, and Huon Aquaculture does about a third of that at something less than $200m/yr. So aquaculture in the south is around 1.5% of the Tasmanian economy, but just in Huon it is a much larger player at something like 20%, with Huon Aquaculture itself contributing about 7% of the total economy of the Huon electorate.

Unless the figures above are wildly out, Tasmania could survive the end of the aquaculture industry, but it would be hard for the Huon without help from the rest of the state if there was a great need to shut the industry down. Aquaculture, in short, is not too big to fail from a whole of state perspective, but looks like that from the perspective of Huon.

In Huon it would hurt a lot. It would be an economic shock on the same scale as the demise of the apple export industry in the early 70s, or the collapse of the scallop industry a decade later.

And right now, it would hurt a lot more than it would at other times. Tasmania is so deeply in debt that we need to reduce the budget deficit by $300m a year for five years in a row to balance the books, and then go further so we have a surplus to start paying down the debt. AI estimates for me that if the salmon industry was wound up the combined effect of loss of income to the Tasmanian government and an increase in social support payments would be around $150m a year.

That would make the task of budget repair half as hard again. Not a pleasant prospect at all. So while the Huon electorate would bear the brunt of economic harm  – the workers and their families most directly, of course – if the aquaculture industry was no more, we would all feel the pain, which gives us all a stake in keeping aquaculture alive. We would feel the absence of the salmon industry’s contribution to the state’s economy in cuts to our early childhood education, our public schools, our hospitals and so on, unless Treasurer Abetz could find a magic way of turning the budget around by $450m a year with no more pain than $300m. Unlikely.

As many people have observed in different contexts, everything is connected to everything else. So we all have an interest in what might be a threat to the salmon industry’s future. There are quite a few such threats, and I think at least one, where the risk of the industry continuing could well outweigh the harm of its being shut down.

But let’s talk about the ozone hole over Antarctica first. It was reported by scientists in 1985. This caused a stir because ozone protects plants and animals from great harm from the sun’s UV rays. Research quickly established the scale of the danger, and the cause – the use of refrigeration gasses called CFCs. In just two years the Montreal Protocol was signed by leading countries, and it came into force in 1989 committing the world to phase out the production of CFCs. The production of CFCs wound down dramatically in the next decade, with new refrigeration gasses taking their place.

The ozone hole was a black swan event. Something completely unexpected, with such serious consequences, that action must be taken immediately and the consequences managed as best can be. There’s a black swan circling the salmon pens too. When the fish get a disease – Piscirickettsia Salmonis has been the major concern – they have antibiotics added to their food. Some of the antibiotic spreads beyond the pen in uneaten food and faeces, but in doses too low to be effective at killing bacteria. That raises the possibility of a plant or fish growing an antibacterial resistant pathogen and perhaps passing that resistance to bacteria that enter our food chain or grow on something we might touch like the sharp edge of an oyster. This risks people becoming ill with an antibiotic resistant disease. Such diseases killed over 6m people last year world-wide. In Australia more people died from antibiotic resistant diseases than on the roads. That is a risk not worth taking for long, if at all.

Warmer waters stress the fish. Stressed fish are more likely to get sick. So in a warming world the risk of needing to use antibiotics increases every year – all other things being equal – which increases the risk of developing antibiotic resistant illnesses in humans. In fact the World Health Authority says aquaculture leading to the development of antibiotic resistant illnesses is a major risk for another global pandemic.

If there was such a pandemic – even if quickly contained to just Wuhan size – that would be a black swan event that would likely lead to a Montreal type protocol very quickly, threatening the future of salmon farming world-wide, regardless of where the pandemic originated.

We could reduce the risk of a pandemic originating from Tasmania if we shut down our salmon industry, or more likely required the salmon companies to take other action to eliminate the need for antibiotic use. I understand moving salmon into deeper, cooler waters would be one strategy. Another is developing vaccines against salmon diseases. A third is selective breeding to increase the salmon’s natural resistance to disease.

Today Huon showed me work on the last two – vaccines and selective breeding. While they said there were promising signs from this work, without having the scientific expertise to judge the likelihood of success of either strategy I couldn’t say more. Except this: if a pandemic could originate from anywhere there is an aquaculture industry, and a solution to common risks of that happening are developed here, that is a very important and valuable piece of intellectual property. So I asked what government support is there for this work? What collaborations with UTAS or other universities or the CSIRO or other research organisation is pushing the research forward? What role are the relevant ministers playing in seeking funding? How engaged is the premier with the effort? This is home territory for me with my background in academic leadership. I would be right on to it in the Legislative Council.

So that’s how my day went. I listened, I tried to learn, and I committed to lead in solving problems with the industry where I could find opportunities to do so. We discussed a longish list! I will rattle through a few more in a bit less depth.

Being a neighbour of a fish farm can be annoying – worse than living next to a pub with a live music scene for noise, and also for light. Can noise be reduced, particularly at night? Bob Clifford might have ideas for that in the longer term, but in the shorter term avoiding stocking leases closer to the coast is the obvious solution. And while illuminating the worksite is important for safety, I don’t see why lights should shine in the windows of folk living along the shore. Has the industry done a study of its light pollution? Could it commit to becoming a ‘dark sky friendly’ business, with lighting re-engineered to only shine down on areas where work is underway?

And for the larger and more fundamental issue, the total impact of the industry on the environment, could salmon farming shift from being seen as a freeloader – whether that is fair or not – to being a model circular economy system? Is there any ‘by product’ which is currently being wasted that could be used as the input to another industry – like uneaten food and faeces from the onshore, fresh water part of the process, being used as fertilizer? Particularly now when farmers are fearing a shortage of fertilizer, this could be an opportune time to develop that value add to what is otherwise a cost. And conversely, how much of the inputs to the industry can be waste products from others, rather than taking from nature itself – avoiding harvesting edible fish to feed the salmon being the obvious example. Can this be eliminated? If not, how low can it go?

What about the waste from the sea pens themselves? I saw clever control technologies minimizing the waste of food, and a drone being put under a pen to film the sea floor, but it seems the only current means of minimising the waste from the fish themselves is the number of fish in the pen and reducing the length of the fish’s life cycle that is spent in salt water. I suspect the only other strategy here is moving the pens out of areas where there is inadequate natural water flow to disperse the fish waste into the environment in such a low concentration that it does not reduce the oxygen content of the waters and suffocate other creatures – like the Maugean Skate in Macquarie Harbour. And does not contain antibiotics making the areas around the pens a training ground for antibiotic resistance.  Then the waste could, I expect does, become useful food for other things. Nature tends to create a circular ‘economic’ system, but this works only if we respect the limits of what it can do as natural systems adapt to our interventions.

Or moving the industry totally onshore. I understand this can be done, but there are two issues to consider. First, we would be replacing the tidal energy which moves water through the open sea pens and cleans them, with electricity to do the equivalent job onshore. Second, if the onshore tanks in which the salmon do their final growth stage ready for market use fresh water, Huon Aquaculture claimed the product would not taste good, which if true would be a serious problem for sustaining the industry in the market. But if the on shore system used salt water, this creates a problem for disposing of the salty fish waste, which would either have to be returned to the ocean, which rather defeats the purpose of bringing the process on land, or sent to landfill which would look to be an even bigger environmental problem than continuing to use sea pens.

What to do? In the high tech industries there is a saying ‘Innovate or die’. That should be a lesson every industry takes to heart, including salmon. Industry has in the past externalised as much of its costs as it can, for example by polluting the environment rather than cleaning up its waste. Nature has been more badly exploited than the most badly treated worker. That has to change. We have to rethink our economy as owing a duty of care to the environment, such that no industrial process is allowed to harm the environment unless the product of the process is too valuable to lose, in which case there should be specific environmental remediation paired with the destruction to produce a net gain for the environment overall.

Most businesses, no matter how well intentioned, will not innovate by themselves. In high tech industries, innovation is needed to keep having a product in the market which is attractive to buyers. In other industries, unless innovation reduces costs or increases quality creating a premium product the market will pay for, innovation is a cost which if one company incurs it, and a competitor does not and undercuts the price of the first in the market, the innovation dies on the vine. I don’t see Coles or Woolworths deciding to stock a more expensive brand of salmon that is farmed more sustainably than a cheaper dirtier rival.

Which raises the issue of regulation and environmental compliance. Currently, fin fish farming in Tasmania is the James Bond of industries – it has a license to kill, or at least to pollute. Admittedly up to certain levels, but that gives salmon farming an advantage over wholly land based food production which allows no escape of pollutants into the environment. The environment act needs to be rewritten to put into law the idea that industry must care for the environment – there are models for this in the EU – and for salmon farming this would mean circular production systems for that part of the salmon’s life on land, and at sea strict real time monitoring in, adjacent to, and randomly at some distance from leases, of every change to the environment which could be causally related to the presence of the pens.

Am I dreaming? I would rather dream than live a nightmare! So, recalling one of my favourite sayings, that history progresses on its bad side, and accepting that in recent times in my part of Tasmania, in Huon, salmon farming has a bad history, is there any reason to be optimistic that salmon farming could go for a great leap forward?

Only if we demand it – and force the government to examine the regulation of the industry, to require it to be nature positive by regulation which forces all companies to play on the same level field rather than the worst environmental performer being able to undercut the others in the market, and gradually increase its share.

Part of that regulation should be looking again at where in Tasmania is suited to environmentally benign salmon farming. I expect that rules out pens in shallower water where nature struggles to provide the waste treatment service the open pen system relies on. I expect that also rules out pens in Macquarie Harbour where as I understand it there is little interchange between the salt water layer of the harbour and the open ocean, and the Maugean Skate is in danger of extinction – which would be a public relations disaster for the salmon industry quite apart from the injury to the species itself and the pain this would cause to its defenders. I expect it limits the growth of the industry. Indeed, it might already be too big, which would be shown if monitoring detected changes to the environment at some distance from the pens, requiring a reduction in the number of pens or their stocking rate. How much of a change to the environment at what distance would of course be a decision for the regulator based on independent scientific advice. But we should be pushing the level of permitted change to the environment down, and the distance at which any effect is found reduced, as quickly as technologically possible. And it would require that the industry accepts that the price of its product must increase to pay the cost of environmentally friendly production, rather than reducing the cost of production by externalising the cost of pollution to the environment – where everyone pays, especially the neighbours of fish farms.

It also means that unless there is some innovation to eliminate the need for antibiotic use in open pens and substantially reduce the other environmental concerns covered above, salmon farming is not a major growth opportunity for Tasmania. In needs to be right sized – an expression commonly used in public debate referring to the cost of the public service, but not usually in relation to private enterprise where it is assumed growth is always a good thing. It’s not. Perhaps there is some opportunity for growth with more of the life-cycle of the fish on land, perhaps with pens further offshore, but what is clear is that the bigger the industry gets, the more likely it is to collapse. Which should not surprise us – it’s a law of ecology after all.

None of this is easy. Nor is it a perfect solution for either the environment or the industry. But I am certain it is the only way we can be confident that the industry will continue long into the future and not follow an under-regulated scallop, or a deaf to political change apple industry, into the history books of myopic government blunders. We, especially the workers of the salmon companies and their families – the people I met at Huon Aquaculture – deserve better than that.

But let’s be clear: the idea that the market determines the price and the environment bears the cost of meeting it is an idea whose time is gone. It needs to be dead, buried and cremated. Let’s do that here, in Tasmania, with salmon, and when it is done we will thank the salmon industry for their leadership.

Work to be done in parliament to be sure!