Tasmania faces a budget crisis. On the most recent analysis by Treasury in the five yearly fiscal sustainability report, if current trends for government income and expenditure continue, we are, they say, on ‘a trajectory that implies severe consequences for the State’s financial sustainability, with rapidly increasing debt servicing costs restricting the Government’s ability to deliver the services the community expects’.

We would be very foolish to allow this to happen, but it will if we don’t take action to change the path we are on. To put some figures around it, if we don’t cut spending or raise taxes or sell assets or some combination of all three, and we keep to our current expenditure course, it is projected that our Tasmanian government net debt ‘could reach $129.5 billion by 2039-40, or $89.4 billion in 2024-25 dollars’.

For our population of 580,000 people that is around $154,000 each. But less than half of the population earn enough to pay income tax – which we can take as a measure of who could afford to pay more state taxes or survive a cut to government services (the ‘social wage’). For those, the debt burden would be around $400,000.

Anyone who has ever had a mortgage of even that size knows that the interest on the debt consumes a lot of your income. Treasury says if we continue our current trend that ‘debt servicing’ cost ‘will become unmanageable’. For while ‘in 2024-25 debt servicing costs were two per cent of operating revenue, by 2039-40 it will exceed 50 per cent’ if historical trends of taxing and spending continue.  Take that in. If we don’t raise taxes, cut spending or sell assets, half of the government’s income will be spent on paying the interest on our debt, before a child born today starts high school. Can’t imagine what the rest of their education would look like.

So well before that we must act, and like climate change that action will need to be more drastic the longer we leave it. Treasury says if we need to spend 10 per cent of the government’s income on interest, while the budget is still in deficit, that ‘would indicate the State’s finances are becoming unsustainable’. This ‘occurs from 2029-30’ if we don’t act. Before a child born today starts kindy. We cannot let that happen!

To really rub it in, Treasury asks us to look at the situation in another way: debt becomes unmanageable when the annual dollar increase in paying your debts is greater than the annual increase in your income. This occurs from 2032-33 on our current path. Around when a child born today starts school. Or when whoever wins the election in Huon is coming to the end of their term. Let’s hope they are up for the work that needs to be done before then.

If you are a late 20’s or early 30’s something who cannot afford private school for your kids, and you can get work in another state, how will these predictions affect your decision on whether to go or stay? And what will it mean for Tasmania when more of our people at this age of family formation, choose to go? We must not allow that to happen.

It’s time for us to grow up. So while there are many things we need to spend more on – in health, education and community services in particular – any suggestion for spending more money now needs to be accompanied by a balancing proposal as to where we can tax more or spend less or what we can sell to pay for it. Otherwise, while we may say where more should be spent, we leave it to others to choose where to cut.

I’d rather say where cuts should be made, to do what I can to make sure the axe falls where it can do the most good for the budget and the most good for Tasmanian society. There are models for this in other countries – prominently Scotland, Iceland and New Zealand in the idea of wellbeing budgets. This is something Tasmania needs to look at carefully. Wellbeing budgets focus our attention on what benefit – or damage – a money budget does, for example, to ‘the different groups of people in Scotland’ in a social impact analysis.

We have a good start on doing this in Tasmania with the Wellbeing Framework adopted by the Rockliff government last year. We need to push the government to develop indicators for the various factors of wellbeing in the Framework, and measures for each, so that we can say where each of the dimensions of Tasmanian wellbeing stand now; predict how they will increase or decrease with various options for budget repair – whether increasing taxes, cutting expenditures and selling assets; and choose the options which maximize Tasmanians’ wellbeing while turning us away from the budget cliff. Plunging over that cliff will cause enormous harm to the wellbeing of all, with the greatest burden falling on those least able to bear it. Which takes us to a more unequal and politically more unstable society.  We only need to look at the US to know that is not where we want to be. I’ve suggested how we can avoid that elsewhere on my web site – have a read of ‘Inequality is poison’.

I am standing for Huon in the Legislative Council because I am prepared to join with Ruth Forrest and any other members who are seeing this crisis for what it is and are willing to do something about it. Ruth has a good idea on how to make change politically possible. Bring a citizens’ assembly together, provide them with all the information they need to understand the problem, and to evaluate options for budget repair. That will not be able to produce the budget, nor can the Legislative Council – that is the role of the government.  But a citizens’ assembly can give the Legislative Council the political strength to say to the government you must set out the financial and wellbeing targets you think Tasmania must adopt to turn away from the economic cliff without hitting the inequality wall, and we won’t pass a budget which predicts our economy and society will fail to achieve those targets. That is a precious power of the Legislative Council. It must be used in this crisis, but used well, which needs truly independent members with experience solving big, hard problems working together for Tasmania. Look at my curriculum vitae if you have not yet done so and you will see I have that experience. Experience which will work for you, for Huon, and for Tasmania.