Tasmania’s finances are in a diabolical position. Unless you are borrowing money on one credit card to pay the interest on another, your budget position looks better than the government’s. Hard to believe but the cost of government crisis is worse than the cost of living crisis.
We have heard about ‘debt and deficits’ for years at election time. Nothing much seems to come of it. But don’t let yourself be comforted by the thought that governments always run budget deficits and it does not seem to be a problem. That applies to national governments which control a nation’s money supply. When the Australian government spends more than it earns, that puts the budget into deficit, and the sky doesn’t fall. But usually the dollar does, and each dollar buys less than it used to. That’s inflation. When a state government spends more than it earns, like Tasmania, that’s more like you and me. We don’t own a mint so we have to borrow to cover the debt, which then incurs an interest payment, and if we don’t quickly earn more than we spend the debt grows and we find ourselves borrowing to pay interest. That’s when we need to talk to a financial counsellor, and rethink our income and expenditure – fast.
In June 2025, before the last election, the Tasmanian Department of Treasury and Finance released the Pre-Election Financial Outlook (PEFO). This is always an important document, because it is not done for and influenced by the current government. It’s written for whoever forms government after the election. The PEFO is like the assessment your financial counsellor might hand you at the meeting – once you’re sitting down.
The PEFO tells us (page 24) that to cover the public service operating costs, new buildings, roads and the like, plus new money required by the Public Non-financial Corporations (mainly Hydro Tasmania, TT-Line (Spirit of Tasmania), TasNetworks, and Homes Tasmania) the government estimated it would need to borrow an additional $2.7bn this financial year. And if instead of more borrowing the government decided to balance the books for the year, the PEFO (page 30) says that would require (this is where we need to sit down) a 25% cut to total operating expenses, or increasing State taxation by 2.5 times, or cutting about two thirds of public service jobs. None of which could happen, of course, but it indicates the scale of the challenge.
How will we meet it? I say we, rather than the treasurer, or even the government, as it will take all of us. Because in the end the government can only do what we the people allow them to do without chucking them out of office at the first opportunity.
So we need to agree on how we got into this mess, and what needs to change to get out of it.
Saul Eslake’s Independent Review of the State’s Finances provided to the Premier and the Lambies (remember them?) in August 2024, before that whole government fell apart and we went to another election, provides the explanations. Saul said that the ‘deterioration’ in the finances of the ‘general government sector’ – taking the government businesses out of the equation – has been caused by the government’s policy decisions to increase spending on operating (the public service’s activities), and infrastructure spending (building or buying new things), as well as reducing state taxes a bit. We’ve got into the habit of expecting government to spend what is required to keep us all happy, rather than what we can afford. To break the habit Saul suggested that the government and all other political parties commit to achieving a series of ‘fiscal targets’ which if met would see the ship of state return to floating nicely rather than taking on water/debt fast enough to threaten sinking.
This seems sensible to me. The government should set out a plan to fix the state’s finances, and a set of milestones to be met along the path. And if the government cannot prepare and manage budgets to meet those milestones, then the parliament should act to require the government to think again, or give up and let the people decide who is best to do the work required.
But I would suggest something more too. It is clear to me that not only has government fallen into the trap of promising too much, they – and we all – have also fallen into another trap: developing the expectation that everything always goes over budget, whether it is spending on schools and hospitals, or building a stadium. And if that’s what we expect, that’s what we’ll get. It does not have to be that way.
I asked Chat GPT to do a diagram for me of the layers of committees that are involved in managing the stadium, from the tradies doing the work to the minister paying the bills. It’s a six story building, which looks like a ‘business as usual’ management structure. But we are not in a ‘business as usual’ situation. We are in a ‘if this goes wrong we are in big trouble’ situation.
We must tighten up our government works and spending control systems, not just to avoid debacles like ferries with nowhere to berth, but all overspending on buildings and programs. In the Legislative Council I would be questioning ministers to give absolutely clear accounts of how – by what chain of command and speed of communication – they know precisely, day by day when things look serious, whether they need to act to keep projects for which they are responsible on time and on budget. And how the appropriate oversight committees of the Legislative Council – the independent eyes we rely on to keep the government accountable – are involved low enough down in the process to know at all times whether the ministers have got things under control.
I have been the academic leader responsible for oversight of a major university building project which would cost about $300m if done today. My job was to make sure that the buildings provided the facilities the staff needed – room by room – and that the cost did not plunge the uni into crisis. Now is not the time to elect people to the Legislative Council and expect them to be able to oversight a government with a history of poor financial and project control who do not have experience like that.